In a recent Private Letter Ruling (“PLR”), the Estate of a deceased taxpayer was granted a 120 day extension from the date of the PLR in order to elect out of the automatic allocation rules of IRC 2632 for Generation Skipping Transfer (“GST”) exemption.[1] At issue was allocation of GST exemption for transfers to certain Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts (“GRAT”) made during the taxpayer’s lifetime.[2] The taxpayer funded 27 GRATs in total, with 3 being in Year 1 (per the PLR), 8 in Year 6, 6 in Year 7, and 10 in Year 9. At issue was the Estate Tax Inclusion Period (“ETIP”) which says that, for purposes of the GST allocation rules, property subject to estate tax inclusion in the transferor’s gross estate is not allocated GST exemption until the end of the ETIP, and then the value used for GST purposes is the value at the end of such ETIP). As discussed below, most transfers to a GRAT are subject to an ETIP until the annuity payments are made, and thus the automatic allocation rules can be tricky navigate.
We have discussed how a GRAT works in prior articles, so I won’t repeat that, but please see the articles linked below for quick primer if you are not familiar with the planning strategy.[3] We’ve also written about the importance of a properly prepared gift tax return, particularly as it relates to GST issues including the automatic allocation rules.[4] When it comes to GRATs, at least in this author’s opinion, the best practice is to always elect out of automatic GST allocation for transfers to the GRAT by electing to not have the Trust treated as a “GST Trust” (as defined in IRC 2632(c)(3)(B)) both in year of the transfer and in all future years by utilizing the election under IRC 2632(c)(5)(A)(ii)). Such election must be made on a timely filed gift tax return.[5] There are a few reasons why this election is important. First, the ETIP prevents an automatic allocation from taking place until the end of such ETIP, at which time, if the GRAT has been successful, the GRAT hopefully has a large asset value which then becomes the value for GST allocation purposes. This is inefficient. If the election out is not made, and the GRAT meets the definition of a GST Trust, then automatic allocation happens whether intended or not. It’s best to avoid this result by electing out, even if just a protective election where you are confident that automatic allocation won’t happen because the Trust is not a GST Trust.
The second reason is the uncertainty of whether the ETIP even applies in the first place, in which case the automatic allocation may happen on the date of the transfer. Treas. Reg. Section 26.2632-1(c)(2)(ii)(A) provides that “the value of transferred property is not considered as being subject to inclusion in the gross estate of the transferor or the spouse of the transferor if the possibility is so remote as to be negligible” and further provides that “a possibility is so remote as to be negligible if it can be ascertained by actuarial standards that there is less than a five percent probability that the property will be included in the gross estate.” There is a lot of uncertainty in this. So, electing out and avoiding that uncertainty is best practice. Of course, most, but certainly not all, GRATs actually have a very small transfer due to the value of the annuity payments reducing the value of the assets transferred, so this may not be a big issue in many cases.
Both of the issues came up in the GRATs at issue in the PLR. In some cases, the GRATs did have an ETIP that later expired, and in at least one case, the five percent rule above was applicable such that there was no ETIP at all. It is clear from the PLR that the taxpayer intended to not have any GST allocated to any of the GRATs. However, through two different lawyers and multiple advisors, some gift tax returns were filed for the earlier GRATs, but no GST election out was made, leaving them subject to automatic allocation at the end of the ETIP. For the later GRATs, it appears that all the advisors, including “taxpayer’s family office”(what were they doing then…) failed to prepare and file any gift tax returns. After taxpayer’s death, the surviving spouse, who was also the executor of the estate, hired new advisors who discovered the issues. At this point, the PLR request was prepared and submitted, and fortunately for all the prior advisors, it was granted such that a GST automatic allocation fiasco was avoided. I often jokingly call the automatic allocation rules under IRC 2632 the “dumb but lucky” rules since they allocate GST where it should be allocated in many cases, but as this fact pattern points out, they also can be the “dumb and unlucky” rules. Fortunately, the extension was granted.
This PLR shows the importance of having competent advisors and having all advisors on the same page. GST planning is complex, particularly when dealing with automatic alloction, as well as GRATs and ETIPs. Some of these elections could have been discussed and slipped through the cracks due to a “who’s on first” scenario between advisors, or they could have just all dropped the ball and not properly advised the taxpayer. Regardless, in the PLR discussed, the decedent’s estate was lucky to avoid the unwanted allocations, but, as with the PLR discussed in my prior article on the importance of a property prepared gift tax return, I’m sure obtaining the PLR was costly and time consuming.
[1] PLR 202633002, August 14th, 2026.
[2] Id.
[3] https://esapllc.com/interest-rates-rise-act-wait/; https://www.esapllc.com/estate-planning-in-volatile-markets-2025/;
[4] https://www.esapllc.com/importance-of-709-2022/
[5] IRC 2632(c)(5)(B)(ii).
