Hafner Case – Refund

Cases, District Court, Income Tax, Tax Controversy

In a recent case out of the United States District Court in the Western District of Washington, the Court granted the Department of Justice’s (“DOJ”) Motion to Dismiss, dismissing the case on multiple fronts.[1] The plaintiff, Ferdinand Hafner (“Hafner”) sought to recover refunds on taxes paid by his late father, recoup amounts he claimed were…
Read More

The Use of Letters of Wishes in Trust Administration

Estate Planning, Fiduciaries

What provides a trustee with information about a settlor’s intent in administering a trust? Obviously, the trust agreement is the most relevant document. However, trust agreements are not always clear, do not always provide context, tend to lack more personal statements of the settlor, and raise many other aspects that could benefit from knowing the…
Read More

Supervisory Approval and the Assertion of Penalties: Palmwood Holdings, LLC v. Comm’r

Charitable Giving, Income Tax, Tax, Tax Controversy, Tax Court

In Palmwood Holdings, LLC v. Comm’r, the United States Tax Court granted partial summary judgment in favor of the IRS, holding that the Service satisfied the supervisory approval requirement of section 6751(b) with respect to a civil fraud penalty first asserted in the IRS’ answer. The decision reinforces a growing body of Tax Court precedent…
Read More

Undue Influence and the Presumption of a Confidential Relationship

Estate Administration, Estate and Trust Controversy

Undue influence disputes[1] often involve no allegations of overt fraud, coercion, or incapacity, instead turning on the fairness of transactions that occur within confidential relationships. A recent Mississippi Court of Appeals’ decision[2] provides a clear illustration of how courts analyze these disputes and why the burden imposed on a beneficiary who occupies a position of…
Read More

A Practical Examination of a Conservation Easement Valuation

Cases, Charitable Giving, Income Tax, Tax, Tax Controversy, Tax Court

A recent Tax Court memorandum opinion[1] presents a thorough illustration of the Court’s approach to valuation disputes in syndicated conservation-easement transactions. As is historically typical in these transactions, the case involved a partnership interest sale shortly before the donation and an associated appraisal asserting a dramatic increase in value when compared to the original purchase…
Read More

Directions